Two ways a battery earns money
Peak shaving cuts the Maximum Demand charge. The battery discharges during the highest 30-minute intervals in the peak window, so the meter records a lower peak. Each kW removed saves RM 97.06 a month on the Medium Voltage ToU tariff.
Energy arbitrage shifts energy in time. The battery charges off-peak at 27.23 sen/kWh and discharges in the peak at 31.32 sen/kWh. The spread is 4.09 sen/kWh before losses.
| Peak shaving | Energy arbitrage | |
|---|---|---|
| Value driver | Capacity and network charge | Peak vs off-peak energy rate |
| Unit value | RM 97.06 per kW per month | 4.09 sen/kWh gross |
| After 90% round-trip efficiency | Unchanged per kW held | About 1.06 sen/kWh net |
| Risk | One missed spike sets the month | Low, small gain per cycle |
| Role in sizing | Primary | Bonus layer |
Energy arbitrage vs peak shaving: a worked example
Take one 125 kW / 261 kWh cabinet on a Medium Voltage ToU site. The kW and kWh figures below are illustrative assumptions, not a datasheet.
- Peak shaving: the cabinet holds 100 kW off the monthly peak. 100 kW × RM 97.06 = about RM 9,700 a month.
- Arbitrage: the cabinet delivers 200 kWh in the peak each weekday. 200 kWh × 1.06 sen × 22 days = about RM 47 a month.
- Ratio: on these assumptions, peak shaving earns about 200 times more than arbitrage from the same hardware.
- Assumptions: 90% round-trip efficiency at the meter, 22 weekdays a month, RP4 rates from July 2025, AFA and SST excluded. Your interval data sets the real kW and kWh.
Size for peak shaving, stack arbitrage on top
In Malaysia, a C&I battery earns its keep on Maximum Demand. Size the kW and kWh to hold your target through every weekday peak, with headroom for degradation. Arbitrage then runs on spare energy at no extra hardware cost.
Arbitrage gains weight on sites with rooftop solar, where exported energy earns only the average System Marginal Price under Solar ATAP and storing the surplus returns more. It still does not replace peak shaving as the anchor for a factory BESS.
Watch for this in proposals
A business case where arbitrage carries most of the saving on a TNB ToU tariff deserves a second look. Ask for the round-trip efficiency, auxiliary load and weekday count behind the figure.
Common questions
What is the difference between energy arbitrage and peak shaving?
Peak shaving lowers the highest 30-minute demand the meter records, cutting the Maximum Demand charge. Energy arbitrage charges the battery when energy is cheap and discharges when it is dear, earning the price spread on each kWh.
Is energy arbitrage profitable in Malaysia?
On its own, rarely. The TNB Medium Voltage ToU spread is 4.09 sen/kWh, about 1 sen/kWh after a 90% round-trip loss. Arbitrage works as a bonus on a battery already sized for peak shaving.
Does one battery handle both peak shaving and arbitrage?
Yes. The EMS reserves enough energy to defend the demand target through the peak window and uses spare energy for arbitrage or solar shifting.
Model both on your load
Send your interval data. We show peak-shaving and arbitrage value separately, with every assumption listed.